Human's Baffle Me

Posted by: Melinda

Tagged in: Untagged 

I have this, apparently, quaint and naive idea that facts and evidence changes people's minds, but a recent conversation with a friend at one of the many science fiction conventions I've attended in the past few weeks has badly shaken this faith in human intelligence.

Here's the background.  Republican rancher faced with a devastating and unnatural drought.  Does he go, "Hmm, maybe 97% to 98% percent of the world's scientist might be right about this global climate thing?"

No, his conclusion -- the terrorists are behind it.  They have found a way to mess with the weather to weaken and bring down the United States.

First off, if the terrorists actually had a James Bond Villain Weather Machine I think they would probably use it so it would rain in the Middle East.  Or they would make a boat load of money improving the climate in Siberia, or having rain arrive at just the right moment in various grain belts around the world.  But no, in his Fox informed world they would use this awesome technology to screw with the U.S.

My take away from all this.  Apparently Occam's Razor is bull crap when you're in this right wing mind set.  Conspiracies are much more fun than those hard knobby facts.  And people are incapable of changing their minds.

Trackback(0)
Comments (5)Add Comment
0
Weather Machine...
written by David St. Albans, August 31, 2011
Actually it was the Sean Connery bad guy character in the most recent Avengers movie that had the super weather machine. But yes, people think terrorists are capable of just about anything. However, the "Above Top Secret" web site has a lot of ultra-liberals who also believe that the Haarp Project in Alaska IS a weather and or earth-disruptive device which causes both tsunamis and earthquakes...See what science fiction does to the mind! LOL!
0
Could it be...Satan?
written by Kevin Andrew Murphy, August 31, 2011
I don't suppose this person would warm to it being pointed out that this is the same logic that blames witches and/or Satan for blighting his crops?

Probably not.
0
What could be simpler?
written by DMS, August 31, 2011
Terrorists want to hurt us.
A devastating and unnatural drought hurts us.
Therefore, terrorists are behind crop failure.
0
The Human Brain is Not Logical
written by Stephen Smoogen, August 31, 2011
My main take away from many years of looking at brain studies is that the human brain has lots of circuits in it to not be logical. The brain has partisan circuits to make sure that views that confirm what one has chosen are kept and ones that do not are ignored. It has feed back circuits to strengthen resolve when faced with overwhelming evidence against it. It is not just right wing brains that do this, but pretty much every brain. It takes a lot of extra energy to always assume one is not right about something and question ones choices and change ones mind when shown one is wrong. Heck it is the reason why there is that old science adage about a theory not being gotten rid of until the last proponent dies. We are stubborn creatures through and through.
0
So That's Why I'm So Tired All The Time!
written by David, September 01, 2011
Stephen wrote:

"It takes a lot of extra energy to always assume one is not right about something and question ones choices and change ones mind when shown one is wrong."

Too right! I spend way too much time expending that extra energy. I'd get so much more done if I let FOX pundits do my thinking for me. Instead, I listen to NPR and the BBC and I'm confused all the time...

Write comment

busy